The uxerhub alternative to Criteria, for product roles
By Sergio Gualda · 6 min read · Updated
Criteria is a talent assessment platform spanning cognitive aptitude, personality, emotional intelligence, risk and skills testing, plus video interviewing and employee development. Its site cites 20+ years of talent science, validation by I/O psychologists and a scientific advisory board, 80M+ assessments completed, and 4,000+ organisations in 60+ countries. uxerhub covers six product roles with twelve written situations read against the capabilities you name. On evidence this isn't a close comparison: Criteria has published validation and we don't have it yet. What we offer is a different question. It asks whether this person fits the role you just described, rather than how capable they are in general.
What Criteria does better
The science, by a wide margin. Its site cites more than twenty years of talent science, validation by I/O psychologists and a scientific advisory board, 80M+ completed assessments and 6B+ data points. That's the evidence base an assessment vendor should have, and we don't have it. If published validity is your requirement, this comparison ends here and Criteria wins it.
Breadth of construct. Cognitive aptitude, personality, emotional intelligence, risk, skills and game-based assessment: a range that covers hiring for any role in the company rather than one function.
It's ISO 42001 certified, which its site describes as the first international standard for AI management systems. For a regulated buyer running an assessment through procurement, that's a document we can't produce.
And it goes past hiring into development (manager check-ins, team diagnostics, coaching), which is an entire product category we're not in.
Side by side
Everything in the Criteria column comes from their own public site. Where they don’t publish something, the table says so instead of guessing.
| Criteria | uxerhub | |
|---|---|---|
| Scope | Any role, in 4,000+ organisations across 60+ countries, for hiring and for development | Six product roles: product designer, product manager, UX researcher, design engineer, front-end engineer and UX writer. Nothing else. |
| What is measured | Cognitive aptitude, personality, emotional intelligence, risk and skills, with game-based options and AI proctoring | Judgment under changing constraints: how someone decides when the brief is unclear and the plan changes. Twelve written situations from the everyday work of the role. |
| Validation | 20+ years of talent science, I/O psychologists and a scientific advisory board; 80M+ assessments completed | Not calibrated: a built instrument, but no published predictive validity, as stated on our own site and not only here. |
| What produces the score | The assessment battery you configure for the role, scored against norms | The role you describe. You say what the job can't do without, and the report is read against it, so the same candidate can read differently for two different jobs. |
| Proctoring | AI proctoring available on assessments | None. Nothing is watched and nothing is recorded. |
| Pricing shape | Enterprise and mid-market sales. The site routes you to a demo. | Five candidates free, then credit packs that never expire. No subscription or seat count, and you don't need a demo. |
Which one you should pick
Choose Criteria if
- You need published validity evidence because of legal exposure, regulation or procurement.
- You hire across many functions and want one validated measure for all of them.
- You need cognitive aptitude or emotional intelligence measured specifically.
- You want assessment to extend into employee development after the hire.
Choose uxerhub if
- Your open roles are product roles, and the shortlist decision is hard.
- You want the score read against what this job needs rather than against a general norm.
- You want a candidate to spend fifteen minutes, not a battery, and to keep their own report.
- You want to try it on one candidate from your pipeline without a demo call.
Why anyone would pick the narrower one
It's a fair question, and it deserves a direct answer.
A validated general measure tells you how capable someone is relative to a population. That's the right thing to know when you're hiring at volume across many roles, and it's why cognitive aptitude testing has survived a century of scrutiny.
It's less useful when you have six shortlisted product designers who are all clearly capable and you need to know which one fits this job. General capability doesn't separate them, because it isn't what differs.
What differs is whether they question a brief or execute it, whether they cut scope or hold the line, whether they can carry a position into a room with a founder in it. Which of those you need depends on the role you're filling.
That's the claim uxerhub makes: narrower than Criteria's, and aimed at the decision you actually have to make.
What we don't claim
We have no published predictive validity. The instrument is built and identical for every candidate, but none of that is validation and we don't present it as such. It's on our own site in the same words.
We're also not an alternative for any role outside the six we cover, we have no development product, and we can't supply the certifications a regulated procurement process will ask for. If that's your situation, Criteria is the correct answer, and this page isn't trying to talk you out of it.
Frequently asked
- Is uxerhub validated?
- uxerhub is built on situational judgment, a format with a long research record in selection, and we'll publish outcome data from our own hires once there's enough to say something solid. Criteria's evidence base is broad and long-standing; if published validity across every role is your requirement, that's a point in their favour.
- Does uxerhub measure cognitive ability?
- No. It looks at what someone chooses to do in twelve situations from the role. If your process needs a cognitive aptitude measure, it needs a psychometric instrument, and this isn't one.
- Can I use both?
- Yes, and for a team already running Criteria that's the sensible shape: the validated battery for general capability across every hire, uxerhub for the product roles where the remaining question is fit to a particular brief.
- How much does uxerhub cost compared to Criteria?
- Criteria sells to enterprise and mid-market buyers and routes you to a demo rather than publishing rates. uxerhub publishes its full pricing: the first five candidates are free, then credit packs at $89 for 5 candidates, $290 for 20 and $690 for 60. Credits never expire, there's no subscription, and candidates never pay.