Hiring scorecard template for product roles
By Sergio Gualda · 5 min read · Updated
A hiring scorecard lists what the role needs, what evidence would show it and how each interviewer rated that evidence. Write it before you meet anyone, because criteria written afterwards tend to describe whoever you liked. Keep it to four or five criteria, each tied to something you can observe.
The template
Use one copy per candidate and per interviewer. Fill in the first three lines once for the whole process, and the rest after each interview.
- Role and level: [Senior product designer, payments team].
- What this hire must achieve in the first year: [one or two outcomes].
- Criteria, four or five: [what the job can't do without].
- For each criterion, the question or exercise that tests it: [who covers what].
- For each criterion, a rating from 1 to 4 and the evidence: [what the person said or did, in their words].
- Overall recommendation: [hire, don't hire or need more evidence], written before the debrief.
- What would change your mind: [the one thing you'd want to find out next].
A filled-in example: senior product designer
Here's what one criterion looks like with the evidence written down.
Criterion: challenges a brief before designing. Question: “Tell me about a time the request you got was the wrong thing to build.” Rating: 3. Evidence: “Described pushing back on a dashboard request, got the PM to look at support tickets, and the team shipped an alert instead. Couldn't say whether it reduced tickets.”
Compare that with “strong strategic thinker, 3/4”. A second reader can check the first version and disagree with it, and that's what makes it useful.
Rating anchors that two people will share
Numbers only compare if everyone means the same thing by them. Write this at the top of the scorecard:
- 1: no evidence, or evidence against it.
- 2: did it when prompted, or only in part.
- 3: did it unprompted, with a concrete example.
- 4: did it unprompted, and can show what changed as a result.
How to run it
Give each interviewer two or three criteria rather than all of them, so they go deep and don't repeat each other. Everyone writes their rating before the debrief, because the first person to speak will otherwise set the tone for the room. In the debrief, start with the criteria where people disagree.
A short pre-interview assessment can feed the same document. Our sample report shows what that looks like, and its interview questions can go straight into your scorecard.
Frequently asked
- How many criteria should a hiring scorecard have?
- Four or five. With more than that, the criteria start to blur together, and nobody remembers them during the interview.
- Should a scorecard include culture fit?
- Not as a label. Name the behaviour you mean, such as “gives direct feedback in writing”, and rate that. “Culture fit” on its own usually records whether the interviewer felt comfortable.
- Can I use a spreadsheet for this?
- Yes. A document or spreadsheet is enough for a small team. What matters is that ratings are written separately and before the debrief.