Structured interview: what it is and how to run one
By Sergio Gualda · 9 min read · Updated
A structured interview asks every candidate the same questions, in the same order, and scores each answer against a scale written before the first interview. Each interviewer scores alone before the panel discusses anyone. It’s consistently among the strongest predictors of job performance in hiring research, and it costs an afternoon to set up.
The four things that make it structured
Most teams think they run structured interviews because they have a list of questions. A list is one of four parts, and the other three do most of the work.
- Same questions for everyone, asked in the same order. Follow-ups are allowed, as long as they dig into the same question.
- Questions that come from the job: what this person will actually face in the first six months, written down before you open the role.
- A rating scale with anchors: for every question, what a 1, a 3 and a 5 answer sound like, in a sentence each.
- Independent scoring: each interviewer scores right after the interview, alone, and the panel only talks once every score is in.
Why it predicts better than a conversation
In an unstructured interview, every candidate gets a different conversation. When the conversations differ, so does what you’re comparing, and most of what ends up being ranked is rapport: who the interviewer clicked with.
The research agrees. A 2022 re-analysis by Sackett and colleagues in the Journal of Applied Psychology, covering decades of hiring studies, put structured interviews at the top of the list of single predictors of job performance, ahead of the general ability tests older reviews had ranked first. Unstructured interviews came out far lower.
Structure also makes the process fairer. When every candidate is scored on the same answers against the same anchors, there’s less room for ‘culture fit’ to mean ‘similar to me’.
How to build one in an afternoon
You need the hiring manager and one person who’s done the job well. Two to three hours is enough.
- List the five moments this person will face most often in their first six months. Think of moments rather than skills: ‘a customer asks for a refund the policy doesn’t allow’, ‘the roadmap changes mid-sprint’.
- Turn each situation into one question about the past (‘Tell me about a time you…’) and one about the job (‘Here’s what happens here. What do you do?’).
- Pick the five or six questions that best separate the people you’d hire from the people you wouldn’t. Drop the rest.
- For each question, write what a 1, a 3 and a 5 answer sound like. Be concrete: a 5 names the trade-off and what it cost, a 1 describes a process without a decision.
- Split the questions across interviewers, so each owns one area, and put the scale in the same document they’ll score in.
A rating scale you can copy
Use one scale for every question, with the anchors written for that question underneath. Example for ‘Tell me about a decision someone senior disagreed with’:
- 1: Can’t name a specific case, or describes one where they gave in without saying anything.
- 2: Names a case but stays vague about what they did themselves.
- 3: Clear case, clear action, but no sense of what it cost or how they’d judge it now.
- 4: Clear case and action, names the cost, and says what happened afterwards.
- 5: All of that, plus what they learned and what they’d do differently, without being prompted.
Where structured interviews go wrong
The common failure is keeping the questions and dropping the scoring. Interviewers ask the right things, then write ‘strong, good energy’ and discuss. At that point it’s an unstructured interview with a script.
The second is questions nobody connected to the job. ‘Tell me about a time you showed leadership’ is structured in form and generic in content. Every candidate has a prepared story for it, and your scale can’t separate a good story from a good leader.
The third is changing the questions halfway through the process because they ‘aren’t working’. If a question really doesn’t separate anyone, fix it for the next role. Changing it mid-process means the first half and the second half of your candidates were scored on different things.
Structured interview vs other methods
A structured interview is strong but expensive: it takes an hour of at least two people per candidate. That’s why it works best as the second or third stage, after a cheaper filter has narrowed the list to the four or five people worth that hour.
A work sample shows output, but it costs the candidate a weekend and gets harder to compare when AI can produce the first draft. A short assessment before the interview shows how someone decides and works, and tells you what to dig into. The structured interview is where you check it.
Frequently asked
- What’s the difference between a structured and an unstructured interview?
- In a structured interview every candidate gets the same questions in the same order and is scored on a scale written in advance. In an unstructured one the interviewer follows the conversation. Unstructured feels more natural and predicts performance much worse, because candidates end up being compared on different things.
- Can I ask follow-up questions in a structured interview?
- Yes, as long as they dig into the same question: ‘What did you do next?’, ‘What did it cost?’. What breaks the structure is changing topic for some candidates and not others.
- How many interviewers should a structured interview have?
- Two or three, each owning a different part of the question set, all scoring alone. One interviewer can run it too, but you lose the check that independent scores give you.
- Is a structured interview the same as a competency-based interview?
- They overlap. A competency-based interview is one way of choosing the questions. It becomes structured when everyone gets the same questions and the answers are scored against anchors.