Interview questions to ask candidates, and how to read the answers
By Sergio Gualda · 9 min read · Updated
The best interview questions to ask candidates are the ones where a strong and a weak answer sound clearly different. That rules out most classics, whose good answers are public. Ask about real past decisions, put people in a situation with no correct option, and ask everyone the same questions in the same order so you can compare them afterwards.
The test every question has to pass
Before you ask anything, picture a bad answer to it. If you can’t, or the bad answer is just a less polished version of the good one, the question measures how well someone interviews and very little else.
That’s why ‘What’s your biggest weakness?’ and ‘Where do you see yourself in five years?’ tell you nothing in 2026. Every candidate has read the same advice, and a chatbot will rehearse them in ten minutes. A useful question makes answers spread out.
Three kinds of question spread reliably: questions about one thing the person did, questions about a situation with no correct option, and questions about how they like to work, where both answers are fine and you’re checking fit with your team.
About past work: what they actually did
Ask for one specific case, then keep asking until you know what they did themselves. ‘We’ is the word to listen for. Strong candidates move to ‘I’ without being asked when you get to the decision.
- Tell me about a decision you made that someone senior disagreed with. What happened next?
- What’s something you started and then stopped? Who wanted it to continue?
- Walk me through the last project that went worse than planned. When did you first see it coming?
- Tell me about a time you changed your mind because of new information. What was the information?
- What did you do last month that nobody asked you to do?
- Which piece of work from your last job would you redo, and what would you change?
Situations: what they reach for first
Describe something that happens in this job every few weeks and ask what they’d do. Make both obvious options cost something, so there’s no textbook answer to give. You’re reading what they protect.
- You’ve got two deadlines on Friday and can only hit one. One is for your manager, one is for a customer. Which slips, and who do you tell first?
- A colleague’s work is blocking yours, and they’re behind because they’re overloaded. What do you do this week?
- You find a mistake in something already sent to a client. It’s small and nobody has noticed. What now?
- Halfway through a project, the goal changes. The work you’ve done is half useful. How do you decide what to keep?
- Your manager asks for something you think is a bad idea, and they’ve heard your objection. Do you do it?
How they like to work: fit, with both answers fine
These have no better answer. They tell you whether this person and this team will make each other’s week easier. Decide what your team needs before the interview, or you’ll end up preferring whoever reminds you of yourself.
- Would you rather ship something and fix it, or hold it until you’re sure? Tell me about the last time you did each.
- When you disagree with a decision, do you say so in the meeting or afterwards?
- How do you use AI in your work today? Show me the last thing you made with it and what you changed.
- What does a manager do that makes you do your best work? What makes you switch off?
- Do you prefer a clear brief or a loose problem? Which have you had more of?
Closing questions: what they want from the job
Keep these for the end, when people are more relaxed. They’re less about judging and more about whether the job you’re offering is the one they want.
- What would make you leave this job in a year?
- What do you want to be better at in twelve months, and how would this role help?
- What haven’t I asked that I should have?
Five to drop
Each is common, and each fails the test for its own reason.
- ‘What’s your biggest weakness?’ One rehearsed answer, given by everyone.
- ‘Why do you want to work here?’ It measures how long they spent on your website last night.
- ‘Where do you see yourself in five years?’ Nobody knows, and everyone knows what to say.
- Brain teasers (‘how many piano tuners are there in Chicago?’). They measure comfort with a party trick and favour confidence.
- ‘Tell me about yourself’ as the whole first question. Fine as an icebreaker, useless as evidence, and it eats ten minutes.
How to score the answers so you can compare people
Write down what a weak, an acceptable and a strong answer look like for each question before the first interview. Two lines each is enough. Then score every candidate on a 1 to 5 scale right after the interview, alone, before you talk to anyone else on the panel.
Scoring alone matters more than it looks. Once one interviewer says ‘I loved her’, the others hear their own notes differently. Independent scores first, discussion second.
Last, ask everyone the same questions in the same order. It feels stiff the first time. It’s also the single cheapest improvement to most hiring processes, because it’s the only way the scores mean the same thing from one candidate to the next. Our guide to the structured interview covers the full method.
Frequently asked
- How many interview questions should I ask a candidate?
- Five to eight in a 45-minute interview. Fewer questions with two or three follow-ups each tell you more than fifteen topics touched once, because the difference between candidates shows in the second and third answer.
- Should every interviewer ask different questions?
- Split them by topic, so each interviewer owns one area, but give every candidate the same set. If interviewers improvise, you end up comparing how each conversation went instead of the candidates.
- Can candidates prepare answers with ChatGPT?
- For the classic questions, easily. It’s much harder for questions about a decision they made themselves, because you can keep asking follow-ups, and for situations where every option has a cost, because there’s no correct answer to look up.
- What are good interview questions for a first screening call?
- Two or three: one about a recent piece of work, one situation from the job, and one about what they want next. Keep the call to twenty minutes. Its only job is to decide who gets the full interview.