Skip to content
uxerhub

Sales interview questions to ask account executives and SDRs

By Sergio Gualda · 9 min read · Updated

Sales candidates interview well because selling themselves is the job, so the usual questions reward charm. Ask instead for their numbers and how they got them, a deal they lost and why, and what they’d do in situations where every option costs something, like a discount on the last day of the quarter. Then run a short role-play and see how they handle being coached.

Why sales interviews are harder than they look

A good salesperson walks into an interview and does what they’re paid to do: builds rapport, reads the room, handles objections. That makes almost everyone look good for forty minutes, and it means the interviewer’s gut is unusually unreliable here.

The fix is to spend less time on how they come across and more on evidence: what they sold, to whom, how, and what happened when it went wrong. Charm can’t fill in a pipeline number.

About their numbers

Ask for exact figures and write them down. Vague numbers are the most reliable warning sign in a sales interview.

  • What was your quota last year, and what did you close? How did that compare with the rest of the team?
  • Where did most of that number come from: new accounts, existing customers, or inbound?
  • What’s your average deal size and sales cycle? Walk me through the longest deal you closed.
  • What share of your pipeline did you find yourself, and how?
  • If I called your last manager, what would they say you should work on?

About how they sell

These show their habits. There are several good styles, so decide which one your market needs before you score.

  • Walk me through the first call of the last deal you closed. What did you ask, and what did you show?
  • Tell me about a deal you lost. When did you know, and what would you do differently?
  • Tell me about a deal you walked away from. Why?
  • How do you decide which deals in your pipeline to spend time on this week?
  • What do you do when a champion goes quiet two weeks before close?

Situations where every option costs something

Describe the situation, ask what they’d do, then ask what it costs. Strong candidates name the trade-off without being asked.

  • It’s the last day of the quarter and the buyer asks for 20% off. You’re short of quota. What do you do?
  • A big prospect wants a feature that’s on the roadmap for next year. Do you mention the roadmap?
  • You’ve got one free afternoon. Prospect new accounts, or call your three biggest customers?
  • A buyer joins and says they have fifteen minutes. Demo straight away, or ask questions first?
  • Your manager wants a deal forecast as committed. You think it’s 50/50. What do you say?

A role-play that tells you something

Most sales role-plays ask the candidate to sell a pen, which tests improvisation and little else. Use your own product, send a one-page brief a day ahead, and play a realistic buyer with one real objection your team hears every week.

Run it for ten minutes, then give one clear piece of feedback and run the last five minutes again. The second run is the important one. You’re watching whether they take coaching, which matters more over a year than how polished the first attempt was.

Account executive vs SDR

For an SDR, weigh resilience, volume and curiosity: how they handle fifty noes a day, how they research an account in five minutes, and whether they ask good questions on a cold call. Past numbers matter less, especially for a first sales job.

For an account executive, weigh discovery, deal control and an accurate read of their own pipeline. A closer who can’t forecast is expensive, because the whole company plans around their number.

Red flags

None of these is decisive alone. Two together usually are.

  • Numbers that change when you ask twice, or only come as percentages of quota with no quota.
  • Every lost deal was someone else’s fault: product, pricing, marketing.
  • They talk through your questions in the role-play instead of asking any.
  • No questions for you about the product, the market or how deals are won here.
  • Feedback in the role-play changes nothing in the second run.

Frequently asked

What are the best sales interview questions?
Questions about exact numbers (‘What did you close last year against what quota?’), about a lost deal and why, and situations with a clear trade-off, like a discount request on the last day of the quarter. They’re hard to answer with charm alone.
Should I ask a sales candidate to sell me a pen?
It tests improvisation in an artificial setting. A short role-play with your own product, a realistic buyer and one objection your team hears every week tells you much more, especially if you give feedback and run it again.
How do I check a sales candidate’s numbers?
Ask for them in the interview, write them down, and ask again in a different way later (‘So of the $900k, how much was new business?’). Then check with references, ideally a former manager. True numbers stay consistent.
Are sales personality tests useful?
They describe tendencies, not performance in your market. Use them, if at all, to choose what to ask in the interview, never to screen people out on their own.